A "carbon neutral" claim on a package is credible only when the company behind it has reduced its own emissions first and used carbon offsets merely to compensate for what remains — and a new international standard plus an incoming EU ban are turning that expectation into a testable rule. Until recently, a company could label a product carbon neutral simply by buying enough offsets to cover its footprint. That offset-only model is now being retired: the ISO 14068-1 standard replaced PAS 2060 in January 2025 with an explicit reduction-first hierarchy, and the EU's Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive will prohibit offset-based climate neutrality claims on products from September 2026.

Decoding 'Carbon Neutral': What It Means for Consumers

At its core, a carbon neutral claim asserts that the emissions associated with a product have been balanced out. What the label cannot tell you on its own is how that balance was achieved — whether the company cut emissions in its own operations and supply chain, or simply paid for projects elsewhere, such as tree planting or renewable energy, to compensate for emissions the product still causes.

That distinction matters because regulators and courts have concluded that offset-based claims can mislead shoppers about a product's true environmental performance, as Devera, a compliance information platform, reports in its explanation of the EU rules. The reason is structural: offsets do not reduce the emissions embedded in the product; they compensate for them elsewhere. A bottle, a t-shirt or a food item carrying a carbon neutral label may have an unchanged footprint, with the "neutrality" purchased at a distance.

Consumer expectations are moving in the same direction as the rules. Climate Impact Partners, a company working in carbon markets, observes that "consumer and investor expectations around carbon offsets are rising, with growing demand for transparency, credibility, and real climate impact," and that both groups increasingly expect companies to prioritize actual emissions reductions and use only high-quality, verified offsets for what remains. Heightened scrutiny of vague claims like "carbon neutral" is part of that shift.

Reduction First: The Core of Credible Carbon Neutrality

A direct emissions reduction means a company measures the greenhouse gases associated with its product — typically following accounting methods such as ISO 14064-1 for organizational footprints, ISO 14067 for product footprints, or the GHG Protocol, according to the sustainability consultancy Circular Ecology — and then works to shrink those emissions: changing processes, energy sources, materials or logistics in its own value chain.

Carbon offsetting is different in kind. It funds emission reductions or removals outside the product's value chain, and those credits are then counted against the product's footprint on paper. Under the older model, a company with an unchanged footprint could buy credits and call the product neutral.

The modern standard closes that path. Circular Ecology, which specializes in carbon accounting standards, explains that ISO 14068-1 introduces a clear hierarchy that prioritizes emissions reductions and removals before offsetting is used, with offsets limited to residual emissions that cannot reasonably be eliminated. In other words, offsets are still permitted — but only as a last resort for what a genuine reduction effort could not eliminate, not as a substitute for one. Devera's guidance puts the same point bluntly: under ISO 14068-1, companies must first demonstrate genuine emissions reductions before any offsetting is considered.